Top Designer

Ok a Vote to see who people think are the best designers in 2 categories ...

Overall Track Design
Graphical Presentation

You may vote once for 3 Designers in each cateogory ... but NOT yourself ....

[ EG ... Overall Track Design - A, B, C / Graphical Presentation - A, B, C ]

Designers up for Nomination are:

Alonsomania
CG
Conrad
Cougar
Crozier
Duffacus
Fish Flake
Flamming Wuzzle
Hermann Tilke
Lee Janotta
Luke
Lustigson
Mac
Magical Trevor
Mandretti39
Mike Wooshy
Pirenzo
Purist
TR
Others - any I have missed out

... this should be interesting if everybody votes

I'd say: Make a poll, that'll encourage many more to vote :).

I thought of that, too, TR, but that makes it more difficult to make your own top-three. And you can't police any misbehaving designers voting for themselves. ;)

Here's my vote:

Overall Track Design
1. Pirenzo
2. CG
3. Mandretti39

Graphical Presentation
1. Pirenzo
2. HTR
3. Magical Trevor

Designers up for Nomination are:

...Hermann Tilke...


AHHAHAHAHAHAHAH ROOFLMMFFAOOL!!!111!!

*ahem*


Please excuse me...

;)

Here's my vote:

Overall Track Design
1. Pirenzo
2. CG
3. Mandretti39

Graphical Presentation
1. Pirenzo
2. HTR
3. Magical Trevor

Hey-thanks Lustig! :)
I must say, I've been working to improve that third-place though lately :)

I'd say: Make a poll, that'll encourage many more to vote :).

A poll has a maximum of 10 Choices

Here's my vote:

Overall Track Design
1. Pirenzo
2. CG
3. Mandretti39

Graphical Presentation
1. Pirenzo
2. HTR
3. Magical Trevor

whos ... HTR ??? (btw thanks for voting for me :))

Thanks Lustig. Wasn't expecting to place in either category, to be honest. I don't post many tracks, except mainly street circuits. Why did I make the list? Give an example of one of my tracks that puts me in the top three of the Overall Track Design. I really don't see myself as a great designer, except for when it comes to street circuits.

My Vote:

Overall Track Design
1. Lustigson
2. Pirenzo
3. Crozier

Graphical Presentation
1. Pirenzo
2. Lustigson
3. Mike Wooshey

Edit --- 1st = 5 Points / 2nd = 3 Points / 3rd = 1 Point

Will Make It Easier

wow :\ urm didnt expect me to be up there on graphical presentation,
but thanks chaynes !! im gonna have to look through the old threat for this one :)
before i vote cuz there are some classics in there.

Designer:
F1Freak
Magical Trevor
Lustig
Fish_Flake

Graphics:
HRT433
Lustig
TR (gotta give it to him, great job with mspaint)
Fish_Flake

Sorry, I chose four for each one, but I can't decide between those I've put down, so none of them are in any particular order.

i forgot about HRT433 ... damn ... he was good oh well my vote is already posted

This is a bit hard, everyone has there own thing that they bring to the "track table" and i cant say who is best at what, but i can say we have some talented people here, who could infact make circuits for a living. So well done everyone really on some great tracks, great ideas. keep it up guys !

BY THE WAY PEOPLE!!!.... Conrad is me (just in case some of you didn't know)...

OK, my votes:

DESIGNERS:
FW
P
CG

GRAPHICS:
HRT433
Lust
P

Sorry if I left someone out that truely deserves to be up there, I can't recall a track which everyone has made... but yea...

I've only put up one track so far, so yeah, I'm not expecting much.

Best Designers:
1. Pirenzo
2. Mac
3. Lustigson

Best Graphics:
1. Pirenzo
2. HRT
3. TR

In response to your comment Mike Wooshy, I am going to be majoring in Civil Engineering in college, and one of my main goals is to eventually design racing circuits (particularly natural terrain road courses).

My Vote:

Overall Track Design
1. Lustigson
2. Pirenzo
3. Crozier

*sniffle* It makes me so proud to be mentioned in such high company :)

*pulls himself back together* Ahem. Right, my votes...

Overall Track Design
1. Pirenzo
2. Lee Janotta
3. FW
4. Lustig

Graphical Presentation
1. Pirenzo
2. HRT
3. Lustig
4. TR

Although I have to say, I do feel this thread a bit harsh, but I guess it's been a while coming. Nothing wrong with a bit of friendly competition. Kudos to absolutely everyone who has contributed to the MyTracks legend. And above all, to Mac, who started it all many moons ago, he just missed out on my top 4, great tracks from him also.

There's too many great deserving candidates for the MyTracks Top Designer Award, but hardly any for the UK General Election... ;)

GO PURIST!!! Live the dream!!! :D :D

What about a way out crazy designs section! :) I do appologise that I dont take things too seriously.. But it helps with the boredom sometimes!

I feel I am not qualified enough to make any nominations either :) But goodluck!!!

Coogz

* those who place 4 people in their votes ... the 4th will be discounted *
( thankyou conrad )

Lets not make this too serious eh CG?

I don't want it to become too much of a competition.

... well im just keeping the loopholes closed, ...

Wow, I'm getting votes, I feel so special....I guess....*shifty eyes*

Overall track design:
1: Lustig
2: P
3: Conrad

Graphical Presentation
1: P
2: Lustig
3: Trev

And thx for the votes ;).

BTW, i agree with P, CG, lets not make this too serious. It's just fun ;).

*lost eyes* --- i know its just for fun ... but youve got too have guidlines in a comp ... :)

All of you guys just wait. I have a big comeback planned...

aww.. how nice, I get left of the list in the first post but I'm still getting some votes :)

I have been too busy with uni and other work, that I haven't posted here for a while, apologies for that, but I will be back

hay sorry ive been busy these last few days
urm
1. P
2. TR
3. Lustig

1. Lustig
2. p
3. HRT

Overall Design:
1. Lustigson
2. Pirenzo
3. Lee Janotta

Graphics:

1. Lustig
2. P
3. Trev

Glad to know no one likes my tracks.

Luke, i like your tracks, ive drawn tracks that have used ideas you have came up with, And ive drawn many tracks using other peoples ideas for corners. im not the best track designer, nor am i the worst, these compatitions are fun, and if you ask me it makes me wanna draw better tracks for next time to prove to people i can draw Good tracks. keep your head up mate you got some bright ideas.

Thanks Mike, I wasn't actually being serious as it's up to you guys on what tracks you like, just I hoped I would at least be mentioned once. ;)

Anyway $**t happens, I don't personaly have a favourite although I really like it when some of you guys use great graphics so we can see them nice and clearly and look professional, therefore I don't have any favourites.

Well, everybody have got their own style and taste. I myself dont figure on that many of the top threes, but that doesnt bother me. I know my designing style is perhaps a bit different :).

CG, why don't you make a total to see how we're doing? :)

ok then ... Current Standings:

http://img132.echo.cx/img132/7683/mytacksvote7cm.th.gif (http://img132.echo.cx/my.php?image=mytacksvote7cm.gif)

a few more people are yet to vote so things can change ;)

a few more people are yet to vote so things can change ;)

Yea, if they want to :rolleyes:

Yea, if they want to :rolleyes:

... i send a PM to all involved and cougar said he doesnt want to vote

... no1 else

Ah, i see. So it's mandatory now, either to vote, or to tell you that one doesnt wanna vote? Interesting.

TR if your against the vote ... dont post in this thread

Design:
1. pirenzo
2. Lustig
3. TR

Presentation:
1. pirenzo
2. Lustig
3. HRT

Now how am I 3rd in track design? The majority of you could beat my tracks into the ground without trying.

I haven't been around here consistently for a while, so I don't really have all the necessary info to make a considered and rational vote.

In which case, in both categories, I vote for myself above all others!

;)

Hey, you started this whole thing Mac, so if anyone has the right to vote for himself, it's you.

TD:

1.F1_Freak
2.Pirenzo
3.CG

TG:

1.Pirenzo
2.Lustigson
3.Flaming_Wuzzle

man,maybe I should draw a track again :rotate:

Design:
F1Freak
Pirenzo
CG

Graphics:
Pirenzo
TR
Trev

... updated list :

Standings (http://img247.echo.cx/img247/4534/mytracksdesignervote8zg.jpg)

Looks like P's a sure winner, there. But I'm happy with silver, too. ;-)