Having watched qualifying live at a pal's who has Sky I then watched the BBC highlight show later on.
In my opinion the BBC won easily. Having a lead commentator in Ben Edwards who knows his business, and has actually won motor races and championships himself makes all the difference compared to Crofty, who would be just as happy commentating on darts.
Coulthard has really upped his game, still races actively in DTM and has experience of last year's Red Bull and Anderson is worth more than Ted and Herbert put together. Georgie is, well just Georgie I suppose.
Sky must review these shows too, and Brundle must know by now they've got a hell of a way to go before anyone in F1 considers them the "lead" UK F1 broadcaster.... not that he'll care too much on his salary.